Seth, Tononi and Block in Nature: today's AI is very unlikely to be conscious
In a joint opinion piece in Nature, Anil Seth, Giulio Tononi and Ned Block give three reasons why today's AI systems are not conscious and machine consciousness is very unlikely. David Chalmers says the arguments are not strong enough, and Seth replied that they are not claiming proof but criticising the overestimation of the probability of AI consciousness.
Who is affected and how
- érdeklődő olvasó
- According to three leading researchers, consciousness is not the same as intelligence, so convincing linguistic behaviour is not in itself evidence.
Sources
- Anil Seth on X: "Three reasons why AI is extremely unlikely to be conscious - and why this matters. Joint opinion in @nature with Giulio Tononi and Ned Block @De_dicto" / Xx.com · Oct 19, 2026
- Seth, Block, Tononi: AI isn't conscious, and probably won't be | AI Weeklyaiweekly.co · Oct 20, 2026
- AI Is Not Conscious, Argue Anil Seth, Ned Block And Giulio Tononi In New Nature Articleofficechai.com · Oct 22, 2026
- Three reasons why AI is not conscious and perhaps never will benature.com · Oct 22, 2026
- Three reasons why AI is not conscious and perhaps never will be | AI Socraticaisocratic.org · Oct 22, 2026
- Nature: Three reasons why AI is not conscious and perhaps never will be | Science News Feed Discussion | RootBadgerrootbadger.com · Oct 19, 2026
- Nature Article Denies AI Consciousness | Humanizehumanize.today · Oct 24, 2026
- Nature Article Denies AI Consciousness | Mind Mattersmindmatters.ai · Oct 25, 2026
Machine-generated summary based on the titles and excerpts of the source articles. The facts come from the linked article.